
First, lets get the negatives out of the way.
Whatever you do, dont watch the commercials for Hearts In Atlantis. The commercials make Hearts look like its strictly sap and supernatural. Its not. Plus, too much of the plot and magic of the film are given away in the commercials.
Also, Hearts In Atlantis is a poor and meaningless title for a movie. It might have worked fine for the Stephen King book, but those not familiar with the novel could be think the plot has something to do with the mythical city. It does not. Or horrors, they could associate this movie with Disneys lame Atlantis.
Now to the positives: Summer must be over, because Hearts is actually a movie with depth and emotion a movie worth remembering.
Hearts does have supernatural elements like Kings The Green Mile, but not as much. Its even more reminiscent of his nostalgic boys adventure Stand By Me.
As with those two movies, Hearts is framed by contemporary scenes. David Morse plays the main character, Bobby, recounting the summer of 1960. We flashback to Bobbys 11th birthday, his adventures with friends Sully (Will Rothhaar) and Carol (Mika Boorem), and his relationship with the mysterious border Ted (Anthony Hopkins).
Anton Yelchin is excellent as the young Bobby. Yelchin resembles a large dark-haired Botticelli angel (he has the belly), but acts like most 11-year-old boys. Hes both tough and sensitive. He longs for adventure, friendship, security and the expensive bike displayed on a revolving pedestal in the store window.
Bobbys mature beyond his years. His dad died years ago and mom (Hope Davis) has a demanding boss so he often takes care of himself. Hes not even surprised when mom calls to cancel his birthday dinner out.
The young man longing for a father figure does not have to spend as much time alone once the kind but rather strange Ted movies in. Its Hopkins who makes Hearts truly memorable. He quickly makes you forget he was ever a cannibal. Hopkins exudes warmth and intelligence while just sitting in a chair talking about the joys of an adult library card.
Ted has Bobby looking out for low men, thugs, who are after him. It is not clear if Ted is totally sane or healthy he has spells but it is clear that theres a bond between him and the boy.
The plot is rather simplistic, a boy and his memories about a favorite year and the people in it with a little supernatural thrown in to heighten suspense. There is a sense of foreboding because of Teds mysterious ways and the people who may, or may not, be after him.
Hopkins never makes a wrong move. The same cant be said of Davis, who is supposed to be shrill and unlikable, but pulls it off too well. Her character is awful, straight out of Dickens. Her part may be small, but its crucial so youd think shed be more interesting than Davis plays her.
Scott Hicks (Shine, Snow Falling on Cedars) directs with grace. The movie has a Norman Rockwell look and is well paced.
Engrossing, suspenseful and sweet, but not sappy, Hearts In Atlantis is the first worthy movie of the fall. Lets hope its not the last. Rated-PG-13 for violence.